| Rk | Team | Record | Rating | Conference | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Louisiana State | (11-0-0) | 0.8692 | Southeastern | |
| 2 | Iowa | (8-1-1) | 0.7755 | Big Ten | |
| 3 | Army | (8-0-1) | 0.7633 | Independent | |
| 4 | Auburn | (9-0-1) | 0.7201 | Southeastern | |
| 5 | Oklahoma | (10-1-0) | 0.6956 | Big Seven | |
| 6 | Air Force | (9-0-2) | 0.6924 | Independent | |
| 7 | Purdue | (6-1-2) | 0.6875 | Big Ten | |
| 8 | Ohio State | (6-1-2) | 0.6868 | Big Ten | |
| 9 | Wisconsin | (7-1-1) | 0.6463 | Big Ten | |
| 10 | Texas Christian | (8-2-1) | 0.5965 | Southwest | |
| 11 | Syracuse | (8-2-0) | 0.5884 | Independent | |
| 12 | Mississippi | (9-2-0) | 0.5846 | Southeastern | |
| 13 | Oklahoma State | (8-3-0) | 0.5649 | Independent | |
| 14 | Notre Dame | (6-4-0) | 0.5585 | Independent | |
| 15 | Southern Methodist | (6-4-0) | 0.5425 | Southwest | |
| 16 | Texas | (7-3-0) | 0.5082 | Southwest | |
| 17 | Clemson | (8-3-0) | 0.4759 | Atlantic Coast | |
| 18 | North Texas | (7-2-1) | 0.4494 | Missouri Valley | |
| 19 | Vanderbilt | (5-2-3) | 0.4455 | Southeastern | |
| 20 | Tulsa | (7-3-0) | 0.4403 | Missouri Valley | |
| 21 | South Carolina | (7-3-0) | 0.4354 | Atlantic Coast | |
| 22 | Georgia Tech | (5-4-1) | 0.4291 | Southeastern | |
| 23 | Dartmouth | (7-2-0) | 0.4123 | Ivy | |
| 24 | Northwestern | (5-4-0) | 0.4089 | Big Ten | |
| 25 | Penn State | (6-3-1) | 0.4057 | Independent | |
| 26 | Florida | (6-4-1) | 0.4055 | Southeastern | |
| 27 | Rice | (5-5-0) | 0.4002 | Southwest | |
| 28 | Alabama | (5-4-1) | 0.3938 | Southeastern | |
| 29 | Houston | (5-4-0) | 0.3925 | Missouri Valley | |
| 30 | Cincinnati | (6-2-2) | 0.3813 | Missouri Valley | |
| 30= | Holy Cross | (6-3-0) | 0.3813 | Independent | |
| 32 | Boston College | (7-3-0) | 0.3802 | Independent | |
| 33 | Pittsburgh | (5-4-1) | 0.3770 | Independent | |
| 34 | Indiana | (5-3-1) | 0.3679 | Big Ten | |
| 35 | Wyoming | (8-3-0) | 0.3643 | Mountain States | |
| 36 | North Carolina | (6-4-0) | 0.3559 | Atlantic Coast | |
| 37 | Kentucky | (5-4-1) | 0.3411 | Southeastern | |
| 38 | Washington State | (7-3-0) | 0.3371 | Pacific Coast | |
| 39 | Navy | (6-3-0) | 0.3321 | Independent | |
| 40 | Georgia | (4-6-0) | 0.3303 | Southeastern | |
| 41 | Duke | (5-5-0) | 0.3244 | Atlantic Coast | |
| 42 | Rutgers | (8-1-0) | 0.3131 | Independent | |
| 43 | Cornell | (6-3-0) | 0.2995 | Ivy | |
| 44 | Florida State | (7-4-0) | 0.2871 | Independent | |
| 45 | California | (7-4-0) | 0.2745 | Pacific Coast | |
| 46 | Illinois | (4-5-0) | 0.2681 | Big Ten | |
| 47 | Missouri | (5-4-1) | 0.2650 | Big Seven | |
| 48 | Colorado | (6-4-0) | 0.2626 | Big Seven | |
| 49 | Tennessee | (4-6-0) | 0.2612 | Southeastern | |
| 50 | New Mexico | (7-3-0) | 0.2591 | Mountain States | |
| 51 | Hardin-Simmons | (6-5-0) | 0.2578 | Border | |
| 52 | Arkansas | (4-6-0) | 0.2541 | Southwest | |
| 53 | Brown | (6-3-0) | 0.2515 | Ivy | |
| 54 | Princeton | (6-3-0) | 0.2360 | Ivy | |
| 55 | Pacific | (6-4-0) | 0.2297 | Independent | |
| 56 | Colorado State | (6-4-0) | 0.2253 | Mountain States | |
| 57 | West Virginia | (4-5-1) | 0.2159 | Southern | |
| 58 | Tulane | (3-7-0) | 0.2096 | Southeastern | |
| 59 | Texas A&M | (4-6-0) | 0.1960 | Southwest | |
| 60 | Arizona State | (7-3-0) | 0.1948 | Border | |
| 61 | Brigham Young | (6-4-0) | 0.1829 | Mountain States | |
| 62 | Mississippi State | (3-6-0) | 0.1785 | Southeastern | |
| 63 | Virginia Military Institute | (6-2-2) | 0.1697 | Southern | |
| 64 | Wichita State | (4-5-1) | 0.1641 | Missouri Valley | |
| 65 | Oregon State | (6-4-0) | 0.1631 | Pacific Coast | |
| 66 | Michigan State | (3-5-1) | 0.1583 | Big Ten | |
| 67 | Southern California | (4-5-1) | 0.1567 | Pacific Coast | |
| 68 | Kansas | (4-5-1) | 0.1540 | Big Seven | |
| 69 | Baylor | (3-7-0) | 0.1486 | Southwest | |
| 70 | Villanova | (6-4-0) | 0.1412 | Independent | |
| 71 | Boston University | (4-5-0) | 0.1321 | Independent | |
| 72 | Oregon | (4-6-0) | 0.1246 | Pacific Coast | |
| 73 | Pennsylvania | (4-5-0) | 0.1040 | Ivy | |
| 74 | Maryland | (4-6-0) | 0.0967 | Atlantic Coast | |
| 75 | Michigan | (2-6-1) | 0.0935 | Big Ten | |
| 76 | Wake Forest | (3-7-0) | 0.0848 | Atlantic Coast | |
| 77 | Harvard | (4-5-0) | 0.0661 | Ivy | |
| 78 | UCLA | (3-6-1) | 0.0513 | Pacific Coast | |
| 79 | Detroit Mercy | (4-4-1) | 0.0367 | Independent | |
| 80 | Virginia Tech | (5-4-1) | 0.0359 | Southern | |
| 81 | Miami (Florida) | (2-8-0) | 0.0274 | Independent | |
| 82 | Texas Tech | (3-7-0) | 0.0273 | Independent | |
| 83 | Iowa State | (4-6-0) | 0.0097 | Big Seven | |
| 84 | Nebraska | (3-7-0) | 0.0076 | Big Seven | |
| 85 | Marquette | (2-7-1) | 0.0028 | Independent | |
| 86 | Minnesota | (1-8-0) | -0.0049 | Big Ten | |
| 87 | Kansas State | (3-7-0) | -0.0102 | Big Seven | |
| 88 | San Jose State | (4-5-0) | -0.0182 | Independent | |
| 89 | Davidson | (5-4-0) | -0.0293 | Southern | |
| 90 | Utah | (4-7-0) | -0.0422 | Mountain States | |
| 91 | Washington | (3-7-0) | -0.0442 | Pacific Coast | |
| 92 | North Carolina State | (2-7-1) | -0.0609 | Atlantic Coast | |
| 93 | Richmond | (3-7-0) | -0.0768 | Southern | |
| 94 | Idaho | (4-5-0) | -0.0789 | Pacific Coast | |
| 95 | New Mexico State | (4-6-0) | -0.0913 | Border | |
| 96 | Denver | (2-8-0) | -0.1010 | Mountain States | |
| 97 | Stanford | (2-8-0) | -0.1181 | Pacific Coast | |
| 98 | Utah State | (3-7-0) | -0.1798 | Mountain States | |
| 99 | Furman | (2-7-0) | -0.1799 | Southern | |
| 100 | Colgate | (1-8-0) | -0.1950 | Independent | |
| 101 | William & Mary | (2-6-1) | -0.2013 | Southern | |
| 102 | George Washington | (3-5-0) | -0.2089 | Southern | |
| 103 | Virginia | (1-9-0) | -0.2308 | Atlantic Coast | |
| 104 | Citadel | (4-6-0) | -0.2316 | Southern | |
| 105 | Yale | (2-7-0) | -0.2664 | Ivy | |
| 106 | Arizona | (3-7-0) | -0.2698 | Border | |
| 107 | Texas-El Paso | (2-7-0) | -0.2899 | Border | |
| 108 | Drake | (2-7-0) | -0.2924 | Independent | |
| 109 | Columbia | (1-8-0) | -0.4783 | Ivy | |
| 110 | Dayton | (2-8-0) | -0.5200 | Independent | |
| 111 | West Texas A&M | (1-9-0) | -0.6024 | Border | |
| 112 | Montana | (0-10-0) | -0.6324 | Mountain States |
Average Ratings by Conference (1958)
| Rk | Conference | Rating | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Southeastern | 0.4307 | |
| 2 | Big Ten | 0.4088 | |
| 3 | Southwest | 0.3780 | |
| 4 | Missouri Valley | 0.3655 | |
| 5 | Independent | 0.2268 | |
| 6 | Big Seven | 0.1977 | |
| 7 | Atlantic Coast | 0.1852 | |
| 8 | Pacific Coast | 0.0962 | |
| 9 | Ivy | 0.0781 | |
| 10 | Mountain States | 0.0095 | |
| 11 | Southern | -0.0562 | |
| 12 | Border | -0.1335 |